We are a team of 8-10 developers working on different parts of a Sitecore instance. In the past we’ve used SVN and more recently (and successfully) Hg, but are moving to using Git as our primary source control. We’re working with Sitecore 7, and using the latest TDS from Hedgehog. In case it matters we’re also using the Glass.Mapper.sc lib from Mike Edwards.
The problem we’re running into, especially compared to how easy it was with Hg, is that merges are a nightmare. It doesn’t help that most of our team is new to Git, but most of us have at least used Hg so it’s not a huge leap. We’ve had so many problems that we moved to a merge-master setup, where the team leads are handling all the merges.
My question is this: From people using these tools, what would you suggest is the best workflow and supporting configuration? A team member suggested rebasing to reduce conflicts, but that doesn’t seem to matter.
Our Hg workflow, which worked very well was: 1) Commit local changes as many times as needed. 2) Pull changes from the server, and update to the remote branch after any merge. 3) Sync TDS. We do this after the pull so that we’re not overwriting the .scproj file in the merge 4) Commit the merge and TDS sync 5) Push the results back to remote
We didn’t have merge nightmares and tds was kept very clean. We tried to adapt something similar with Git and have wasted a lot of time each week to resolve issues.
We currently have each dev working in their own branch because of the merge errors working with everyone in master. The type of merge issues I’m seeing seem to mostly come from what Git merges automatically. I definitely don’t want to merge everything by hand every time, but I wouldn’t mind doing project file merges by hand. We’re using Sourcetree and I have BeyondCompare Pro.
Any suggestions, especially coming from successful implementations, would be greatly appreciated. If there are simply config changes that can be made or a change to our workflow to make the process more reliable I’d love to learn about them.
14
So there’s a lot of things in this question I don’t know about, but I feel like proper application of a .gitattributes file might solve many of the conflicts. http://git-scm.com/book/ch7-2.html
For example, there are some files we have where people are always adding lines, rarely removing them. So a line in similar to *.tds merge=union can help take care of all the conflicts. Without understanding Sitecore and TDS a bit more I’m just guessing on your exact needs, but this hopefully should get you started down the right path.